Should I use outsourced IT services or build it in-house?

More and more businesses are choosing to outsource their IT teams instead of building them in-house, especially as personnel costs rise while the demand for continuous operations continues to grow. But this is not the right choice in every situation. This article analyzes common IT outsourcing models, compares the pros and cons with in-house operations, and provides some considerations for businesses before making a decision.

Maintenance & Development

What is outsourced IT services?

Outsourced IT services are a form of business where a company transfers part or all of its information technology operations to an external entity to be managed, instead of hiring and maintaining an in-house team. The scope can include three layers:

  • User support (IT helpdesk).
  • Operation and monitoring of the system.
  • Maintenance and development of the application.

It is necessary to distinguish clearly between outsourcing IT services and hiring a freelancer.

Freelance hiring is hiring an individual for a specific job. When they finish the job, they leave; there is no one to replace them when they are busy or on leave.

True outsourced IT services involve hiring an entire organized operation: there are people working, there is a manager, there is a process for handling issues, there is a commitment to response time, and there is a plan for replacing personnel when necessary. This is the most important difference and is also what determines whether the company can truly reduce its risk.

Common IT outsourcing models

The market currently has three main models, differing in the extent to which businesses retain operational control.

Rented by the head of the department.

The business assigns a specific task to the outsourced IT team. This model is suitable for projects (with clear start and end points), but it does not address the daily operational needs.

Hire additional personnel.

The company already has an IT team but lacks personnel in some positions, so they hire additional staff to join the existing team. This approach is flexible and quick, but the company still has to manage the daily work of the hired staff itself, set up the processes, and take responsibility for the results.

Hiring a full operational team with a hierarchy.

The business entrusts the entire operational aspect to a team organized by level, with a management point and a commitment to service. This model is commonly known as Application Management Services, It is usually divided into three layers:

  • The layer that receives and processes the user's basic requests (Help desk)
  • System operation and management layer
  • The deep processing layer includes roles for developing and operating infrastructure.

The hierarchical structure is not just a way of organizing personnel. Its true purpose is to ensure that each type of problem is handled at the appropriate level of competence, so that the company does not have to pay a high-level engineer salary for basic requirements that a frontline support staff can fully handle. This is the mechanism that helps optimize costs while maintaining quality.

The real cost of building an in-house IT team

Don't just look at the salary!

When calculating the cost of an internal IT employee, in addition to salary, there are also insurance and benefits, recruitment costs, time spent training before the person can effectively work, equipment and tools costs, and what few people consider is the cost of replacing employees. Every time an operations engineer leaves, the company spends time recruiting a replacement, training the new one, and more importantly, losing the system knowledge the former employee did not fully hand over.

The table below compares the two options based on factors that are often overlooked.

Factor Internal IT IT outsourcing
Cost structure Fixed costs do not decrease when workload is low Costs are based on the scale and scope of the agreed service
Setup time Calculated in months, depending on the hiring market Significantly shorter
Risk Direct interruptions require recruitment and retraining The partner responsible for assigning replacement personnel
Flexible in scale Difficult, related to staffing and personnel procedures Adjusting according to each stage
Operating outside of working hours Expensive, requires shift scheduling and compensation Option based on the need
Systematic knowledge Located in the minds of a few individuals Documented according to the handover process
Right of control The highest Depend on the quality of the service commitment

The notable point in the above table is the last row. Outsourcing gives up some direct control in exchange for stability and flexibility. This is a real trade-off, and businesses need to look at it squarely rather than assuming that outsourcing is only beneficial.

Outsourcing IT services

Operating IT is also a customer service issue.

BSV notes that most discussions about outsourced IT services revolve around technical capabilities. Those are necessary elements, but not enough.

Operational reality shows that the vast majority of a team’s day-to-day workload is not serious infrastructure issues. It’s hundreds of small requests from within the company itself and end customers (such as being unable to log in, slow machines, not knowing where to navigate, needing access permissions). These requests are not technically difficult. The difficulty lies elsewhere.

The requester is usually busy and somewhat annoyed. They describe the problem in user language rather than technical language. They need to be answered within a predictable timeframe, and they need to know where their request is in the queue. A technically skilled IT team that answers in a hurried manner, without updating the progress, and without knowing how to ask again to clarify the issue will create frustration even when they handle it correctly.

In other words, the team that handles IT requests operates according to the logic of a customer service department.

This is why organizations with a foundation in customer service operations often have an advantage in this area, even though that isn’t what people think of first when looking for an IT partner. The ability to recruit and train a large number of staff for the position of receiving requests, experience in designing processing procedures and escalation, and a habit of measuring by response time index and satisfaction level, along with the discipline of operating in shifts, are things that have been built over many years and are very difficult to replicate in the short term.

When evaluating a partner, therefore, it is advisable to ask an additional question beyond the usual technical questions: what do they measure the quality of meeting requests with, and how do they train frontline staff? The answer will reveal quite a lot about the experience that your employees and customers will receive on a daily basis.

When should outsourcing be used and when shouldn't it be?

Outsourcing often works well with what is already standardized, and poorly with what is still vague. If you don't know what you need, the first step is not to find a provider but to clarify the process and scope of work.

Outsourced hiring is usually a reasonable option when:

  • The workload is large enough that it requires a dedicated person, but not enough to hire a complete team.
  • When businesses need support outside of office hours but do not want to arrange in-house shifts.
  • When the current IT team is being consumed by operational tasks that take up all the time that should be dedicated to development projects.
  • Or when the business needs to expand quickly to a new market and cannot recruit staff in line with the business's progress.

Conversely, there are cases where outsourcing is not a good option.

  • If the system contains core competitive secrets and allowing outsiders access is a strategic risk, the business should keep it internal, even if it costs more, unless an absolute security mechanism can be built.
  • If the internal process is not standardized and the business itself has not yet described the work to be done, outsourcing only shifts the chaos to another side without solving the root problem.
  • If a company does not have anyone with the authority and capacity to act as the focal point for managing partners, the results will often not meet expectations because no one monitors whether the service commitments are being properly implemented.

Criteria for selecting partners

After deciding to outsource, choosing the right partner is just as important as the initial decision. Here are a few criteria to consider.

  • The partner has many years of experience and has successfully implemented projects of similar scope, scale, and industry sectors.
  • Service commitments must be specific and measurable. SLA, That is, there is a clear response time and processing time for each level of severity, rather than just general promises of dedication.
  • The handover process and documentation needs to be clearly defined from the beginning, because this is what determines whether the company will become permanently dependent on the partner. A good partner will proactively document everything so that the company can hand it over to its internal team or to another entity if necessary.
  • Security capabilities need to be demonstrated by certification (such as ISO 27001, SOC 2 Type II…), and have specific policies, not just verbal commitments, especially when the partner has access to the system.
  • The ability to provide stable staffing is a factor that is often overlooked but has a direct impact on quality. If the partner also has difficulties recruiting staff, the company will indirectly bear the burden of that problem through the constant turnover of staff.

The principles for choosing this partner are not much different from those for choosing a partner in general. Tips for choosing a BPO company for outsourcing Generally speaking.

Conclusion

Outsourcing IT services is not a way to cut costs at all costs, but rather a way to transfer part of the operational risk to a unit that is better able to handle it, while optimizing opportunity costs by freeing up internal staff from repetitive tasks so they can focus on creating value.

This decision should start with a clear understanding of the actual workload of operations, the cost-effectiveness of the self-service option, including hidden costs, and a clear definition of the scope of work to outsource. When evaluating partners, in addition to technical capabilities, businesses should consider their ability to handle requests and train frontline staff, as this has a significant impact on the daily experience of employees within the organization itself.

If your business is considering this option, discussing it with an organization that has experience implementing it in practice will help you better determine the appropriate model and scale before making a decision.

Related Articles
Scroll to Top

Let BSV help you gain deeper insights through a 1:1 consultation session